Potbelly Sandwich Shop logo

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Start with a good default.

Start here

Best first order at Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Fast chain with a protein-forward default that still stays practical, led by Turkey Breast & Swiss (Originals). Simple grilled picks and smaller portions are usually the easiest first moves here.

Nutrition source checkedNot medical advice
Best first order

Chicken Cordon Bleu (Skinny)

490 cal·40g protein·15g fat
SmallGentleProtein-forwardSmall bite

Best for: Good when a smaller appetite means the normal order would be too much.

Watch if: Higher sodium can add up quickly; this order has 1,400mg sodium.

How to order: Order the Chicken Cordon Bleu on Skinny (thin-cut) bread — grilled chicken with ham and Swiss.

Keep in mind

Menu watchouts

Quick notes for choices that may feel heavier.

More
  • Portion creep: Keep the order simple and stop at comfortable instead of finishing by default.

Use this as a quick read, not a hard no.

What do you need today?

Pick a situation first. If you want to tighten the list further, use more filters after that.

More filters

15 curated options.

Other good options

Use caution

Turkey Breast & Swiss (Skinny)

350 cal·28g protein·8g fat
SmallGentleEasy protein

Best for: Good when a smaller appetite means the normal order would be too much.

Watch if: Higher sodium can add up quickly; this order has 1,060mg sodium.

How to order: Order the Turkey Breast & Swiss on Skinny (thin-cut) bread.

Higher fiber

Turkey Breast & Swiss (Originals)

520 cal·43g protein·14g fat·6g fiber
SmallGentleProtein-forward

Watch if: Higher sodium can add up quickly; this order has 1,550mg sodium.

How to order: Order the Turkey Breast & Swiss on Originals size — lean turkey breast is one of the best GLP-1 picks.

Use caution

Ham, Mushroom, Egg & Swiss (Skinny)

460 cal·32g protein·16g fat
SmallGentleProtein-forward

Watch if: Higher sodium can add up quickly; this order has 1,430mg sodium.

How to order: Order the Ham, Mushroom, Egg & Swiss on Skinny (thin-cut) bread — a protein-packed breakfast sandwich.

Use caution

Smoked Ham & Swiss (Skinny)

390 cal·27g protein·12g fat
SmallGentleEasy protein

Watch if: Higher sodium can add up quickly; this order has 1,280mg sodium.

How to order: Order the Smoked Ham & Swiss on Skinny (thin-cut) bread.

Use caution

Tuna Salad & Swiss (Skinny)

460 cal·30g protein·20g fat
SmallNausea watchProtein-forward

Watch if: Higher sodium can add up quickly; this order has 590mg sodium.

How to order: Order the Tuna Salad & Swiss on Skinny (thin-cut) bread for a lighter tuna option.

Higher fiber

Chili Bowl

370 cal·23g protein·16g fat·6g fiber·10g sugar
SmallGentleEasy protein

Watch if: Higher sodium can add up quickly; this order has 1,400mg sodium.

How to order: Order the Chili Bowl — hearty and protein-rich with good fiber.

Use caution

Smoked Ham & Swiss (Originals)

590 cal·41g protein·20g fat
SmallNausea watchProtein-forward

Watch if: Higher sodium can add up quickly; this order has 1,890mg sodium.

How to order: Order the Smoked Ham & Swiss on Originals size — lean ham with Swiss cheese.

Use caution

Roast Beef & Provolone (Originals)

610 cal·42g protein·21g fat
SmallNausea watchProtein-forward

Watch if: Higher sodium can add up quickly; this order has 1,300mg sodium.

How to order: Order the Roast Beef & Provolone on Originals size — solid protein with moderate calories.

Compare two options

Pick two options below and we'll show them side by side.